Ingredient Selection Consulting Service
Choosing right from the start costs less than fixing it later
The most expensive mistakes happen before production starts
Of all the mistakes we see clients make, the most expensive ones do not happen in the factory. They happen when there is nothing yet but an idea.
That is, choosing the wrong ingredient from the outset.
There are three common patterns. The first is choosing an ingredient because it is trending: seeing that an ingredient is popular and deciding to use it without checking whether it suits the intended product format, then discovering later that it turns cloudy, precipitates or is too bitter to drink once in the formula.
The second is choosing an ingredient with good research data, but where the dose used in the research is too high to fit into a single capsule, or so high that the cost exceeds the planned selling price.
The third is choosing a plant with legal restrictions, then discovering when applying for approval that it cannot be used in that product category, or that additional approval is needed, which takes several months.
All three have something in common: they are discovered after the investment has been made, and they could have been avoided with a few hours of discussion before starting.
What this service does for you
This service does not sell extracts. It sells the right decision, and it is the only one of our services that sometimes ends with us recommending you buy an ingredient elsewhere, if that is the right answer for your brief.
The reason we offer the service this way is simple. Clients who get honest advice the first time tend to come back for their next project, while clients who are sold something unsuitable never come back.
How we work
Step 1: Understand the business brief first

We start with questions that have nothing to do with ingredients: who this product is sold to, what the selling price is, which channels it is sold through, which existing products it competes with, and how you want customers to feel about it.
These answers define all the constraints. For example, a product priced at two hundred baht has a clearly limited raw material budget per unit, a product sold through pharmacies needs different supporting data from one sold online, and a product for export has documentation requirements that affect ingredient choice from the outset.
Step 2: Screen possible ingredients
Based on the brief, we propose several ingredients that could meet it, with comparative data across four dimensions: supporting research data, compatibility with the product format, cost per product unit, and legal status.
We do not propose a single ingredient and call it the best, because this decision involves trade-offs that you should see and choose for yourself.
Step 3: Check legal requirements
We check whether the chosen plant and ingredient can be used in that product category, whether there are dose conditions, and whether additional approval is required, based on the legal framework for each product category (Notification of the Ministry of Public Health (No. 293) B.E. 2548, 2006; Cosmetic Act B.E. 2558, 2015; Herbal Products Act B.E. 2562, 2019).
This is the step that saves clients the most money, because problems are discovered before any cost has been incurred.
Step 4: Set the right specification
Once the ingredient is chosen, you still need to decide what percentage of key compound you require, a decision that has a major impact on cost. We calculate backwards from the amount that must go into the formula and the raw material budget per unit to find the right point, rather than choosing the highest value achievable.
Step 5: Define safe communication boundaries
What clients rarely get from extract suppliers is advice on what they can and cannot say. We prepare guidance on what level of communication the available data supports and where it goes beyond what the law permits, so the marketing team can work without creating risk.
Service formats
One-off consultation A meeting with a summary report of recommendations, suitable for a clear brief that needs a quick answer.
Consultation throughout the project Covering everything from ingredient selection and specification to coordination with the manufacturing plant, suitable for brands without their own technical team.
Review of a project in difficulty For cases where you have already started and run into problems. We analyse where the problem lies and what solutions are available, which may mean changing the ingredient, adjusting the formula, or sometimes repositioning the product instead.
Pre-purchase review For those with offers from several suppliers who want an impartial opinion on which offer is best value, including checking whether the figures in each supplier’s documents are genuinely comparable.
What you will receive
A report comparing the options with the pros and cons of each, a summary of the legal status of the ingredients considered, a recommended specification with the reasoning, an estimate of raw material cost per product unit, communication guidance within the legal framework, and a list of questions to ask suppliers before deciding.
Questions we will ask in the first meeting
So that you can prepare, here are the questions we ask and why each one matters.

Who is this product sold to? This determines the product format, the channels and the level of data required.
What is the intended retail price? This determines the raw material budget per unit, which is the hardest constraint in ingredient selection.
Which channels will it be sold through? Because a product sold through pharmacies needs different supporting data from one sold online, and the channel determines marketing costs, which take up a share of the selling price.
Which existing products does it compete with? Because choosing the same ingredient as competitors means you have to compete on price or marketing, while choosing a different one opens the opportunity to compete on something else.
Do you plan to export? Because this affects ingredient choice from the outset. Some ingredients can be used in Thailand but are restricted in other markets.
Do you already have a manufacturer in mind? Because the limitations of the production line determine which raw material formats can be used.
What level of technical knowledge does your team have? So we can adjust the level of explanation and identify which parts we need to handle for you.
How much time do you have before launch? Because this determines which options are actually feasible. Some take several months, which may not fit your plan.
What often changes after the first meeting
From experience, about half of our clients change some part of their plan after the first discussion.

The most common change is the product format, for example from a drink powder to a capsule, after finding that the desired ingredient has a taste problem that is not worth fixing.
Next is reducing the key compound content, after seeing that the value originally set would push the cost above the planned selling price.
And quite often the ingredient is changed altogether, after finding that the intended ingredient has legal restrictions or is already widely used by competitors.
These changes happen before any cost has been incurred, which is the whole value of this service.
Why the best advice is sometimes not to do it
A consulting service that earns its fee by steering clients towards production has a built-in incentive to always recommend going ahead. We have chosen to position this service differently, because in the long run, clients who are stopped from pursuing a loss-making project are the ones who come back to us with a better project.
There are only a few situations in which we usually recommend slowing down or stopping. The first is when the ingredient the client intends to use is already sold as a commercial raw material at a price lower than the cost at which we could produce it. In this case, developing it yourself offers no advantage beyond the feeling of having something of your own, which is not worth several hundred thousand baht.
The second is when the claim the client wants to use is not permitted under Thai law. However good the extract, if what makes the product appealing is a statement that cannot be made, the project has no way forward in marketing terms, and going ahead with production first and working out how to write the label later is doing things in the wrong order.
The third is when the target market is too small to recover development and registration costs within an acceptable time. We show you this figure in the first meeting, because it is not hard to calculate and it is the number most likely to change the decision.
The fourth is when the client does not yet have a confirmed sales channel. Having a good extract with nowhere to sell it is a harder problem to solve than having a channel and looking for an extract. We therefore usually recommend testing the market with commercially available raw materials first, then investing in developing your own once sales have proven themselves. This sequence means the large sum of money is spent when risk is at its lowest.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Q: Do I have to buy extracts from Zubb Biotech as well?
A: No. This service is completely separate from product sales, and we have clients who used this service and then bought ingredients from another supplier because it was a better fit, which is an outcome we are happy with.
Q: How is this different from consulting an ordinary extract supplier?
A: Suppliers have an incentive to recommend the products they have. That is not wrong, but it is a limitation you should be aware of. This service separates the consulting fee from sales, so we can advise without that condition.
Q: I have no idea yet. Can I still use the service?
A: Yes, and that is when this service delivers the best results, because nothing has been invested yet that needs protecting. We start with the target group and market opportunity, then look for ingredients that fit the brief.
Q: I already have a local raw material but don’t know what to do with it. Can you help?
A: Yes. This is a common brief from community enterprises and local businesses. We assess which valuable compounds the raw material contains, which markets want it and which product format suits it best.
Q: How many days does it take?
A: For a one-off consultation, we send a summary and recommendations after the meeting within the time frame stated in the quotation. Project-long consultation follows the timeline of that project.
Q: How do you charge?
A: We charge according to the agreed scope of work, with a clear price stated before starting. For clients who go on to use our manufacturing service for the same project, we deduct part of the consulting fee from the manufacturing fee under the agreed conditions.
Next step
Send your brief to [email protected] or LINE @zubbbiotech, whether it is a product idea with no ingredient in mind yet, a raw material you have but don’t know what to do with, or a project that has run into problems. We will assess the scope of work and come back with a quotation as soon as possible.
Contact us and request a quotation
Send us the details of your project via Contact us or LINE @zubbbiotech · Tel. +66 89 056 5651 · +66 97 297 1777 · Email [email protected]
References
- Notification of the Ministry of Public Health (No. 293) B.E. 2548 Re: Dietary supplements, as amended. (2006, February 2). Royal Thai Government Gazette, 123(Special Part 18 Ngor).
- Herbal Products Act B.E. 2562. (2019, April 30). Royal Thai Government Gazette, 136(Part 56 Kor), 1–29.
- Cosmetic Act B.E. 2558. (2015, September 8). Royal Thai Government Gazette, 132(Part 86 Kor), 5–28.